Hi Everyone,

I’m in the market for a new WiFi router or mesh system. My previous Asus gaming router often crashed and reset, and I’d like to avoid such issues.

Key Needs:

•	Stability for multiple phones, laptops and smart devices (lights, plugs, cameras)
•	Good Range & Speed
•	User-Friendly
  •     Ability to connect about 8 Ethernet devices

Budget: Reasonable, prioritizing value.

Would love to hear your recommendations, especially if you have a smart home setup. Thanks a lot!

  • momsi@lemmy.worldEnglish
    3·
    11 months ago

    I am very happy with my Omada setup. It’s an ecosystem, not a single device. I use an er605 as router and eap610 as AP. I also have a switch, probably you don’t need that, and I now have an Omada controller (you can also host that in as a docker container, so not strictly needed). For wifi you can simply throw another ap somewhere and have excellent Mesh wifi. It’s more complex than a simple consumer router, but also has a lot more functionality.

    • 𝙚𝙧𝙧𝙚@programming.devEnglish
      2·
      11 months ago

      Does the controller software have to run 24/7 or only when you need to make config changes?

      I’m looking into the Omada ecosystem and wondering if the hardware controller is crucial or a convenience that can be deferred.

      • momsi@lemmy.worldEnglish
        1·
        11 months ago

        The controller does not need to run 24/7. The controller configures the devices and the config remains on the devices. Though, when your devices are adapted by a controller, you cannot access any settings on the devices themselves, only via the controller.

        Maybe should add: depending on the network set-up, I’d strongly recommend getting a hardware controller. For me, I have one server hosting all my stuff. I also hosted the controller with docker in this server. Which ends up being a single point of failure, and no way to look into your routing if your server is down/unreachable. I got a hardware controller (oc200) eventually just to separate my interner and network infrastructure from my hosting and service infrastructure.

      • lemming741@lemmy.worldEnglish
        1·
        11 months ago

        The controller also handles roaming, as I understand it. I have a software controller on a VM. They provide a .deb! I have 3 EAP670s and an EAP-655-Wall. Roaming works perfectly on phones and laptops. I have a hidden SSID on each individual AP that I use to lock dumber stuff. Some devices fight the AP Lock on Omada.

        I see the value in going 100% omada, but I couldn’t justify the cost of the switches I’d need. Their routers look good for the price too, but my use case is a notch or two above their target market.

  • 𝙚𝙧𝙧𝙚@programming.devEnglish
    1·
    11 months ago

    I’d recommend giving the ASUS Merlin firmware a try if you feel up to it. It might work out better than stock firmware if that’s what you’re running.