Say I want to link to community x on instance y.org. How do I post this so that someone from instance z.org will end up at z.com/c/x@y.org, but someone from a.org ends up on a.com/c/x@y.org?
With Lemmy it’s !Magazine@instance.org
From kbin it’s the same but with an @ instead of !.
IDK how others have search set up. There may not be a wayDid you mean to link that specifically to kbin?
No. Just an example, but I used this sub after editing my comment
Well from what it looks like, on my instance, is that your
!technology@beehaw.orgis linking tohttps://kbin.social/m/!technology@beehaw.org.I think what OP is after, is a way to make it link to the reader’s own instanced version of
technology@beehaw.orgI was under the impression that the exclamation mark was designed to do exactly that: take everything after the
!and interpret thecommunity@instance.exampleinto whatever the user’s instance uses for links (m for kbin, c for lemmy).Some day there will be a standard link style… for now it seems like a huge mess :'D The ! doesn’t work on kbin (for me, at least), nor do links with c/ where we use m/, but the @-link does, which is neat considering I’d not found any short link style that did until seeing that one :'D Seems like others think the !-link is the thing to do, some give absolute links, some try other things besides. Growing pains, teething issues… might as well say “wheee” while the ride’s still bumpy .
I did some investigation into this in https://codeberg.org/Kbin/kbin-core/issues/199, but stopped short of actually fixing it or spinning up an instance to investigate further, as just didn’t really have the time and energy (and haven’t yet).
Fixing the
!links probably isn’t too hard, but I’m not one to try anything without being able to run it. And really there should be an alias for /c/. I haven’t used Symfony so can’t tell if it’s as easy as I hoped. I’ve had countless times where I thought something would be easy but it turned out hard and vice versa…
I’m not sure that’s correct. When I click your first link, it’s going to
https://kbin.social/m/!technology@beehaw.org. What OP wants is a way to post the link and (in my case) go tohttps://melly.0x-ia.moe/c/technology@beehaw.org
The best way is to use relative links, such as !technology@beehaw.org
What I did there was simply
[!technology@beehaw.org](/c/technology@beehaw.org). This link doesn’t start with the protocol and site, but instead assumes the current site, and starts with/c/my_comunity.tld, meaning it will be routed to the same instance.This will probably not work for those on Kbin, since their communities (magazines) don’t start with
/c/, but rather with/m/. If anyone knows a good way for this to work for both, I’d be glad to adopt that myself going forward.In my phone, for some reason, Jerboa crashes when I tap your link.
That’s a known bug in Jerboa. It’s already been reported and the dev acknowledged it.
For kbin at least, there’s currently a Firefox add-on that adds an icon next to any full or relative links that sends them to the corresponding kbin magazine version of the lemme community.
So if I copy the pink text it should work if I understand correctly?
It does, thank you!
This seems to be a good topic to plug my GitHub issue that would make !technology@beehaw.org correct clickable links with no extra effort on the users part. I even broke down how to implement that change in the codebase!
A “link community” button in the formatting bar below the comment box would be ideal.
Relative links seem to be the best way to accomplish what you’re looking to do. So, in your example, it’s
/c/x.org.Reference: https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/post/6063
That seems to be the only option that works.
Took this from the sidebar at newcommunities
[link text](/c/community@instance.com) This provides a link that should work across instances, but in some cases it won’tTo my knowledge this doesn’t work if a user in your instance hasn’t previously searched for the community
