• 0 Posts
  • 14 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 17th, 2023

help-circle


  • Totally agreed, but there are pros and cons.

    File - harder to steal but once stolen hacker can bruteforce it as much as it wants. Web service - with proper rate limits (and additional IP whitelist so you can only sync on VPN/local network) - its harder to bruteforce. (But yes, you (sometimes) have also full copy locally in the local client, but …)

    If it was only for me I probably would also go with KeePass as you will not update the same db at the same time, but with with multiple users it’s getting unmanageable.

    I just got triggered as those CVEs are not that bad due to the nature that the app encrypts stuff on the client side so web server is more like shared file storage, while your answer suggested to switch to a solution that doesn’t work for a lot of people (as we already tried that).












  • I’m very interested in other people setup and performance.

    I only have RPi4 8GB running with HA + Frigate (+ few other addons) running from my old USB2 2TB spinning drive + additional usb coral. Based on my observations, my setup should support 2-4 cameras.

    Without usb coral the cpu did spike a lot, as it was using cpu trying to detect objects on video, but the performance was very poor (like 0.5 frame/second), with usb coral there is no difference between detecting or not.

    There is 3 part you need for cameras.

    1. USB Coral - if you want to have person/animal/object detection, without it it will work, at least it did work for me, but don’t know how reliable it was. object detection only run when movement is detected, but without coral it did peek the cpu with poor detection fps.
    2. Memory - It will store raw frames for processing, and need extra memory for providing jsmpeg previews.
    3. CPU - is the biggest issue, you definitely need something with hardware decoding, and if you want to add watermark on video also encoding, decoding performance is very important as it need to do that to decode video into images to perform movement detection, and it does that all the time.

    My one 1080p camera set to 15fps (+ very complex mask) use: Memory: I see it’s using like 900MB for my 1 camera currently while there is some wind that trigger a lot of motion, so don’t know how it will actually scale with one camera, and . CPU: At one time I managed to go down to 70% core usage when there was not activity on camera, currently with high wind I see usage 100% sometimes even spikes to 200% with a lot of movement detected, so my CPU would handle 2 fine, 3 should work, more - depends on probably on the amount of movement per camera, (without usb coral it was 400% on any movement).

    What I would buy depends on how many cameras you want. Good spinning drive for video should be enough for most setup. I would go for 1GB per camera with few GB fee for OS, as reading code from spinning drive shared with cameras would be painful if you run out of memory. CPU - something with intel quick sync, and I would look very closely how many decoding streams it can support at once (or dedicated gpu with video decoding). The amount of cpu will depends highly of the configuration, camera resolution, camera fps, detection resolution, detection fps, applied masking (cutting portion of the video from detection), Now that I’m thinking, my cpu went from 70% to 100% core probably because I did add second (very complex) mask. But the CPU on RPI4 is probably very slow in comparison, so I would aim for … low tier core per camera? Gogole Coral (or GPU once the support will be implemented) for object type detection, unless you have very powerful cpu and not many cameras and it just works for you :)